Go to Ceras Newsletter Homepage

Pakistan Peace Coalition



Commission on Security

The Pakistan Peace Coalition Conference resolves to set up a Commission on security, comprising Air Marshal (Retd). Zafar A. Choudhry (convenor), Dr. Mubashir Hasan, Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy, Mr. Shahid Kardar and Brig (Retd) A. R. Siddiqui and Mr. M. B. Naqvi, with the following terms of reference:

A) to examine the implications of nuclearisation and suggest confidence building, arms control and disarmament steps necessary to protect the people of Pakistan and the sub-continent against the danger of a nuclear war;
B) to determine the parameters of legitimate security arrangements for Pakistan;
C) to prepare an alternative defense policy and affordable defense budget.

The commission may coopt new members as and when required and call upon experts, specialists, and activists for the realization of its objectives.The commission is requested to present at least its first report by May 28' 1999.

Commisssion on Minorities

Convinced that the treatment of minorities in South Asian states contributes to confrontation and conflict both within their societies and between states, the Pakistan Peace Coalition Conference resolves to sponsor a meeting of eminent personalities from the South Asian region to decide on the modalities of setting up a high-level South Asia Peoples' Commission on Minorities and determine its terms of reference and procedures. The Conference nominates Ms. Asma Jahangir as the convener of the eminent persons' group and requests her to report to the Coalition not later than June 15, 1999.

More than 500 enthusiastic peace-mongers gathered here in the first conference of its kind in the region to demand an end to the nuclearisation of the region and a no-war pact between India and Pakistan as a followup to the message of peace and goodwill generated by the meeting of the Prime Ministers of both countries in Lahore last week.

Organised by the Pakistan Peace Coalition (PPC), a national body formed following the Indian and Pakistani nuclear tests of May, the two-day Pakistan Peace Conference, had a distinctly South Asian flavour, with the attendance of some 30 Indian delegates who got Pakistani visas literally at the last minute, while at least one senior scientist was refused permission to attend from the Indian government, as well as activists from Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Nepal besides over 400 from all over Pakistan.

PPC comprises the various organisations working for social justice in different cities. Its members are basically activists who found their agendas overtaken by the nuclear issue following the May 98 tests. Delegates to the conference, besides NGO representatives, included economists, film-makers, journalists, lawyers, doctors, trade unionists, women's rights activists, scholars, retired army personnel, students and artists.

There is a symbolic significance in choosing Karachi as the venue, said conference convenor B.M. Kutty, pointing out that this city has been in the news as a violence prone area. This conference sends out the message that this city and its people ardently desire peace, not only for themselves, but also for all those who live in this country and in the region. Peace in this city is essential to the emergence of a meaningful peace movement in Pakistan.

"Until May, all those working for peace and justice presumed a continuity of state and society, commented Zia Mian, a Pakistani physicist currently teaching at Princeton University, USA. Nuclear weapons threaten that continuation as nothing else has ever done."

He was one of the overseas delegates who flew to Karachi especially for the conference. Also from the USA was journalist and researcher Lawrence Lifshultz, who co-edited a book published last year 'Hiroshima's Shadow', an anthology that explodes the 'myth of Hiroshima' - popular beliefs that justify the USAs nuclear bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August 1945.

"The gathering here has interrupted my pessimism," commented Lifshultz, who is currently working on another publication on nuclearisation.

"It's been very inspiring", commented well known Indian activist and columnist Praful Bidwai, who has been at the forefront of the anti-nuclear movement in his country.

What's very encouraging is that the Pakistan-India Peoples Forum for Peace and Democracy demands, considered utopian just a year ago, have infiltrated the official agenda - people to people contact, reducing tensions and negotiating through dialogue. So what's happened at this conference could also influence what happens at policy or state level.

Talking about the principal tool the state has employed to subdue civil society - the bogey of national security, PPC organising committee member and Director of the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, I.A. Rehman in his keynote address commented that the nuclear tests had delivered a most foul blow to peoples interests by raising the spectre of their extinction.

Perhaps it was this spectre that galvanised the spirit of volunteerism so evident at the conference, to attend which most Pakistani and overseas participants had paid for their own travel - with the organisers only taking care of room and board in addition to the registration fee of PKR 200.

The spirit of cooperation was also very evident in the response to Bombay-based film-maker Anand Patwardhans announcement of the peace march due to start from Pokharan on May 11, the anniversary of the first Indian nuclear test last year. Hundreds of participants signed the petition he circulated, along with donating at least one rupee each to contribute towards the march totalling over one thousand rupees by the time the conference ended. photo

People are the best guarantee for peace, commented Nirmala Despande in her address to the opening plenary, attended by some 800 people. She was one of the two Indian members of parliament who attended the conference. The common man is still sound and peace loving. All that is needed is mobilising the people for action to build a peaceful society. Her counterparts from the Sindh provincial assembly attending the conference nodded agreement.

Many justify the nuclear tests of last May by saying that a balance of terror has been created and therefore the danger of war between India and Pakistan has disappeared. A view that I.A. Rehman is not prepared to give credence to because I am not prepared to credit the apparatuses governing us with the ability to break out of the suicide pact they have painstakingly created.

Besides the element of human error, he noted, was the point that nuclear weapons have nowhere created a balance in favour of sanity they have only unleashed a mad race for deadlier weapons of mass destruction. Above all, they do not cause havoc only when they are used in war; their presence in a country itself causes grave harm to the state and the civil society.

Nine working groups, ranging from 25 to 60 participants each, deliberated various questions from the nuclear issue perspective. The idea, rather than announcing a charter of demands, was to spell out what society wants and to give a direction to the struggle to achieve it, explained conference organisers, who are hoping that participants would return to their areas armed with a better understanding of what peace means in today's conditions, and how best to politically mobilise people around a peace agenda.

This conference is a rare opportunity for activists to get together, commented scholar Hasan Gardezi, who, like many is wondering if the peace movement in Pakistan can become an agent of social change.

Islamabad-based political activist and development economist Kaiser Bengali agreed. "There is a need to link movements like this to a larger effort. Isolated, stand-alone efforts don't bear fruit", he told IPS as charged participants did a symbolic round of the conference venue on the last night, singing songs, and holding aloft flaming torches and white flags.

"We need to make it part of a larger political effort to restructure the state, otherwise it will just be part of what I call Pepsi politics - there's a bit of fizz and then everything settles down. This mustn't be allowed to fall by the wayside like previous efforts."

- Beena Sarwar

Go to Ceras Newsletter 15 Go to Page Top